I have made a basic Mario theme I want to get in, on Mario theme - Pastebin.com. These are the roles; Princess Peach's Kingdom: Mario: Nightkiller. Knows Luigi Luigi: -5 Voteshield and protect. Knows Mario Princess Peach: Has a vote of 5. Can distract Toad: Can vote Wario: Can protect Waluigi: Can inspect in the day Yoshi: Can inspect at night Evil Kingdom: Bowser: Daykiller. Bowser Jr: Night killer. Has a vote of 2 Boo: Can distract. Goomba: Can poison Monty Mole: Can inspect Traitors: Dark Koopa: Nightkiller. Can kill twice a night. Has a vote of -1 Para Trooper: Can kill once and distract. Koopa Trooper: Can inspect Shy Guy: Can Poison, revealed as Toad Magikoopa Squad: Kamik: Can kill and poison. Knows team from the start Magikoopa K: Can kill, shared Magikoopa P: Can poison, shared Magikoopa apprentice: Can convert into either Magikoopa K or Magikoopa P randomly. Please test it, I would really like to have my theme made official MOVED TO MAFIA REVIEW AND IMPROVED
Kamek* Taking a quick look at the theme there are some balance issues. In 7p games it is just Mario and Luigi against 2 Traitors and 3 Magikoopa. If Mario dies the village instantly loses since Luigi has negative votes.
Another thing is that in larger games the village is pretty OP. Two vigilantes, one of who knows one of their teammates, and two inspects. Village could easily connect with each in no time at all. Unless you want this to be a kill fest I highly suggest removing Bowser's bomb on distract, because really distracting isn't affecting Bowser in any way (unless you give him an extra action,) so there's really no point in adding that in. Magikoopa is pretty UP because the only thing they are offering are night kills and poisons, which I hope are shared. If they weren't shared this would just be a kill fest. Village is relatively small compared to other villages. You didn't add in a Miller which is surprising, but what I'm really surprised about is the fact that you have zero bodyguards in this theme. Maybe make Magikoopa Apprentice a bodyguard instead since he works for the big boss. Also maybe you can make Shy Guy a miller for the village and maybe Wario as a bodyguard? Two vigilantes is not the way to go. Your spawn is horribly unbalanced, such as the 7p games. I have advice to fix that but I gtg soon so I will tell you soon. So yeah, this has potential but needs a lot of work. Make sure you take all my suggestions and take notes on them. Also Vet, Luigi doesn't have a negative vote, he has a voteshield of -5.
Ah misread that. Still, the balance is pretty off. There shouldn't be more than twice as many mafia as village.
Updated it to include the balance. I also made the Magi's kills and poisons shared, and Shy Guy into a Miller. Wario is a bodyguard now too, and I got rid of Princess Peach's death if she distracts Bowser I've updated it to include more things. mostly the errors you pointed out.
I had an idea for a Mario theme but only Mario. He starts as a villager or a mayor and can /convert(needs flavour) to randomly become things from his games like Go-Kart Mario, Strikers Mario, Golf Mario, Basketball Mario, and Superstar Mario. Each of them have different powers. Just a thought.