So, I noticed we don't have a Mario theme. Uhh....WHAT? GOOD GUYS Mario: You're the Mushroom Kingdom's Hero! You can do /stomp (name) during the daytime to stomp an enemy! Since it's in broad daylight, you will be revealed when you stomp. Of course, you know who your brother is. Luigi: The under-loved sidekick of Mario. Luigi can do /protect (name) to protect someone during the night! Of course, you now who your brother is! Peach: The princess that always gets kidnapped. You can do /inspect during the night and have it announced at the daytime! Of course, since your the princess, you get a vote shield of -1. Daisy: The noisy cousin of Peach. She can do /poison during the night to poison people with her poisonous flowers. Her flower aura also gives her a vote shield of -1. Wario: The fat rival of Mario. You can do /fart (name) during the night to distract someone during night. Of course, since no one trusts you, you get a vote of 0.5. Waluigi: The tall rival of Luigi. You can do /cheat during the night to know a random person on the enemy's team! But since absolutely no one trusts you, your vote isn't worth anything, and when you have a vote on you, it's worth 2. Yoshi: The poor dinosaur always getting chucked down a pit. You can do /flutter during the night to fly up to the clouds in the day time and find out information about a friend! Toadsworth: That one old toad. Since your so old, you can't really do much. But you can use /tell Peach or /tell Mario to tell them that you are Toadsworth. Your vote is also worth 2. Toadette: That one noisy pink girl toad. You can do /scream during the daytime to scream out and tell a random person's role. Toad: Ah, the Toad. You're a fungi, but you can't really do anything other than vote. BAD GUYS Bowser: Bwahahaha! You're the almighty bowser! And you can do /stomp (name) and /scorch (name) during the night to remove 2 people! Bowser Jr.: The son of Bowser. With your paintbrush, you can do /paint (name), covering them in poisonous paint, so they die the next night! Goomba: Oh. You're a Goomba. Well you can vote, but if you want you can just do /taunt and it will announce your name and taunt Mario to stomp you... Koopa: That one poor green turtle. Well when Mario tries to stomp you, you will go into your shell, so don't have to worry about that. You also have a vote shield -2. When in your shell, you can do /spin (name) to knock yourself into a person, removing them from the game. Kamek: That one witch EVERYONE hates. You can do /disguise (name_role) on a person so that when inspected, they will show the selected role. Dry Bones: Oh boy. Well you can do /disassemble (your name) to protect yourself during the night! But since your just a heap of bones, your vote is worth 0.5. Spiny: That one spiked Red Koopa. You can't do much, but you have a counter attack when you are attacked! Spike: The green monster that pukes huge spiked balls...Wat. ANYWAY, you can use /throw (name) to throw a spiked ball at a person with having a 50% chance of hitting. If it misses, your role will be revealed. Boo: Sneaky little ghostses you are. You can do /sneak to sneak into the good guys team and reveal a random person's role from the other team. When revealed, it is showed to everyone on your team. Neutrals Antasma: Conquering people's dreams wasn't enough. You can do /create every night to have a 50% chance of making 1 bat, 30% chance of making 2 bats, and 10% chance of making 3 bats or no bats. Also during the night, you can do /kill (name). You can only do the amount of attacks according to the number of bats you have created, and you can't use a /create and a /kill on the same night. Fawful: Oh dear, that one crazy-googly-eyed-green-evil-dude. Well you can do /distract during the night time thanks to you're googly eyes. You can also do /kill during the daytime. SOMEHOW, nobody sees you. MESSAGES (put before every in-game message) ±Mushroom: Mario, or (name1) comes up to stomp (name2)! Before (name2) can scream for help, (name2) takes (name1)'s brown boot to the face. (name1) mushrooms (name2)! Toadette comes into everyones face and screams: "(name) is the (role)!" Then Toadette runs away from the angry mob. A Spiny was attacked, and looks severely hurt. But boy does he look pissed. Yoshi flew up to the clouds and found some useful information! (if yoshi) (friendly role) is (name)! Waluigi sneaked out in the night, and caught up on some useful information! (if waluigi) (enemy role) is (name)! (name) was covered in Bowser Jr.'s poisonous paint! Bleck! A spiked ball was attempted to be thrown at (name1) but it missed! (name1) twirls around to see the culprit, and he notices it is (name2). (death message) (name) had no 1-ups left! Uh-oh...GAME OVER. (if enemy side wins) Bowser's forces control Peach's Castle, as the Mushroom Kingdom is no more... (if good guys win) Bowser's forces has been cast out of the Mushroom Kingdom, allowing them to live on for more days to come! (entry message) Bowser is attacking...AGAIN. But this time, more people are getting involved. Join Mario, or Bowser, in the fight to control the Mushroom Kingdom! Final Thoughts Hope you really take this into consideration. And honestly, I felt like we really needed a Mario theme. So anyway, tell me what you think below, and...Yeah. Anywho, cya!
Instead of putting the help messages, you could simply explain what each role can do (e.g.: Mario: Revealing daykill, knows Luigi). This way is much easier for people reading this thread to understand what each role can do. You should organize the roles by their teams. It's impossible to know even how many sides there are in this theme. I recommend you use more generic commands. All those /stomp, /scorch and stuff are going to get many people confused. Use them only when really necessary. Also, you have lots of "Of course," on your help messages.
I'm thinking of adding in Fawful and Antasma into a team of their own. (villains from Mario & Luigi RPG games) Okay, I added them to the list above.
I don't like this idea because what you said is not true. In PO2, there is a Mario theme with Toad and Toadette. Super Smash Brawl is also a "Mario" theme.
The Bad Guys side is too big. There are 9 different roles there, while Village has 10 different roles. To make things worse, each of the baddies has a command, so unless this is a theme with 2 villages (no one knows their teammates), then village would simply have no chance of winning. I disagree with you. PO2 is not PO1, lots of themes there are only being tested or joke themes. Also, Mario Bros has a rich universe that could very easily deserve its own theme despite sharing some roles with SSBB. SSBB doesn't stop Kirby and Zelda themes from being unique, so it shouldn't do the same to Mario.
What I'd do is branch out, creating something with these sides. Mushroom Kingdom, aka village. Koopa Krew, mafia1 Frantic Fish, a side with Cheep Cheep and all those new crazy fish. Make that mafia2 Boos, a side with King Boo and such. Make that mafia3. You can have an indie baddie role in Pokie. Have it live a few hits before it dies. Wiggler would be a cool indie side too, turning into a much stronger form after "killed" or voted the first time. I'll probably edit later, but definitely branch out and try to diversify. You'll be surprised with what you come up with once you start to stray from the usual cast of characters.