Yeah sorry, when i added the teamtalk i updated it with a previous version that still had clean curse and winifdeadroles for brony0 , when i will log on i will re-add them.
Also, you have Brony having a voteshield as high as -5 as early as games of 8, which means the village will usually never have any counter to him and will have to rely on a crossfire. I suggest maybe adding Applejack to the mix or lowering his voteshield.
Actually that voteshield was -4.1 during the previous update, but that too was lost when i have added teamtalk and returned to be -5 voteshield, when i will log i will bring back those lost updates. So there is no need for Applejack. Edit: Finally re-added the old updates, it should be OK now.
(16:48:32) S. Kirby: [Team] who's on my team (16:48:53) Sky Sentinel: [Team] hi (16:50:05) Sky Sentinel: does parasprite not see changeling's teamtalk (16:50:07) Sky Sentinel: :( (16:50:10) S. Kirby: no (16:50:14) Sky Sentinel: lame (16:50:15) S. Kirby: I didn't see you talk at all For Peluche Parasprite: "teamTalk": [ "cadance", "chrysalis1", "chrysalis", "changeling", "changeling1", "dchangeling"], For Changeling: "teamTalk": [ "cadance", "chrysalis1", "chrysalis", "changeling", "changeling1"], For Parasprite (non-peluche): "teamTalk": [ "para", "para1", "discord"], This is just awkward and confusing.
http://server.pokemon-online.eu/mafiathemes/FiM_stats.html According to this Brony has made a massive impact. Sure his win percentage is low in smaller games, but that's because it's easier to x-fire. As it gets larger though, Brony wins more than half the time and has done so consistently. At this time, I suggest reformatting the mafia so you have Discord and 2 Diamond Dogs instead of Parasprites, Changeling, and Brony.
Never, one of the distinct aspect of small games of FiM that differentiate it from Default is that there is only one single team killer inside the game, weakened by the fact that they are not connected. I have already bargained to maintain this aspect intact when i removed the second parasprite in exchange of brony because before the Discord team winned too much, so i prefer to change how puppets and Brony instead then give up to this aspect of FiM.
That's nice and all, but you literally give the village no option but to either wait for an x-fire or trick the Mafia into voting Brony, but when you have people not knowing they're Berry Juice or something it's impossible. What are they supposed to do, just ignore the role? There's no feasible way for the village to truly counter the Brony.
You forget that if village destroy the other mafia teams Brony loses his voteshield. And from what i see who is disadvantaged now it's not village but Discord's team.
I did not forget that, but let's keep in mind that beforehand the main village PRs weren't able to claim due to Changeling. Now is no different except there's a role just sitting there with a giant voteshield and, if went after just once, the game usually goes downhill from there.
Sorry but i still fail to see your point about village disadvantaged, from the stats it seems that village wins nearly the same amount of time like Brony, what is disadvantaged it's Discord's team now not Village. And you forget that actually Fluttershy can hax Twilight, Twilight can Hax Spike and Spike can hax Rarity so a minimum of connection exist. Anyway i have noticed that one of the problems why Brony wins so much it's that "winifdeadroles" doesn't work to make him unable to win if those roles are alive, so village continued to lose even when they can outvote Brony, so i fixed that problem with a more complicate solution. And now Brony instead to start with -4,1 voteshield it starts with -1,1 voteshield that rises of -1 voteshield extra every time that they collect a new villager or Power Role. I have thought about the Changeling and Parasprite too, so now when both of the are Peluche they will know each other Peluche.
No idea what it means, but I got this message after getting lynched. Was told to post on the forums. (23:32:44) ±Mayor Mare: Xenon (Changeling) has been banished from Equestria! (23:32:44) ±Game: Oh noes, now that all the bad guys are dead, the price of Brony's dolls has dropped down, now you have lost your now Brony is without voteshield Here's the gamelog: Spoiler (23:26:34) Times Up! : (23:26:34) The Roles have been Decided! : (23:26:34) ±Game: You are a Changeling! (23:26:34) ±Game: You are a changeling, a ponylike minion of Queen Chrysalis! You can /feedoff (poison) of someone's emotions, leaving them empty after a turn, and avoid most distractions. You are also allied with Discord and the Parasprites, but forget who they were. You appear as an ordinary pony when inspected, and may see what happens around town. Converts Paraspries when defeated. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (23:26:34) ±Game: The Changeling is Xenon! (23:26:34) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:26:34) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Hades, Noivern, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:26:34) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:26:34) ±Time: Night 1 (23:26:34) Make your moves, you only have 40 seconds! : (23:26:34) *************************************************************************************** (23:26:34) Sky Sentinel: in the ovaries (23:26:37) Sky Sentinel: huh (23:26:38) BestBubs.: Lol (23:26:39) Truthful Karp: oh look (23:26:39) Baby Jane left the channel. (23:26:41) Hades: I PONIES (23:26:41) ±Exploud: Hades was muted for caps for 15 minutes. (23:26:41) ±Slay: Hades will be slain by Murkrow after the phase ends! (23:26:44) Crobat: I am a tailor (23:26:44) Sky Sentinel: GG (23:26:44) Truthful Karp: ima weird role (23:26:44) Xenon: rip (23:26:45) Noivern: im spike (23:26:45) BestBubs.: Rip (23:26:45) Micaiah: lmao (23:26:45) Crobat: looooooooooool (23:26:49) -Dranzer Kai-: hades was slained hax (23:26:56) Noivern: hax (23:26:56) Goobes: im derpy (23:27:02) ±Game: You have chosen to feedoff Noivern! (23:27:06) Crobat: I'm crying (23:27:07) Xenon: [Team] hi (23:27:12) Sky Sentinel: inb4 ts (23:27:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:27:14) Times Up! : (23:27:14) ±Game: Oh Yeah! Another piece added to Brony's collection, still 3 to go! (23:27:14) ±Game: A Pony has been converted into a Doll Berry Punch! (23:27:14) ±Game: Your target (Noivern) was poisoned! (23:27:14) ±Mayor Mare: Noivern (Pony) has disappeared from Equestria! (23:27:14) ±Slay: Hades (Pony) was slain by Murkrow! (23:27:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:27:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Parasprites, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:27:14) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:27:14) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:27:14) ±Time: Day 1 (23:27:14) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (23:27:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:27:17) Sky Sentinel: oh (23:27:17) Sky Sentinel: ok (23:27:25) Xenon: hades is pony (23:27:25) Xenon: hax (23:27:26) Sky Sentinel: well (23:27:28) Crobat: ofc Hades couldn't be mafia (23:27:35) Truthful Karp: yeah (23:27:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:27:44) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Parasprites, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:27:44) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:27:44) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:27:44) ±Time: Day 1 (23:27:44) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (23:27:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:27:50) ±Game: You are a Changeling! (23:27:50) ±Game: You are a changeling, a ponylike minion of Queen Chrysalis! You can /feedoff (poison) of someone's emotions, leaving them empty after a turn, and avoid most distractions. You are also allied with Discord and the Parasprites, but forget who they were. You appear as an ordinary pony when inspected, and may see what happens around town. Converts Paraspries when defeated. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (23:27:50) ±Game: The Changeling is Xenon! (23:27:56) Xenon: [Team] can you see this (23:28:01) leon left the channel. (23:28:01) Crobat: what there are no weird roles (23:28:02) FoxOp left the channel. (23:28:10) Sky Sentinel: brony is pretty weird (23:28:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:14) Times Up! : (23:28:14) No one was voted off!: (23:28:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Parasprites, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:28:14) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:28:14) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:28:14) ±Time: Night 2 (23:28:14) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (23:28:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:34) Crobat: er (23:28:41) ±Dratini: GameGod was muted by Strudels for 2 hours! [Reason: Inappropriate] [Channel: Tohjo Falls] (23:28:42) ±Game: You have chosen to feedoff Veteran Padgett! (23:28:44) Crobat: I changed my job to fashion designer...or something idek (23:28:45) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:45) Times Up! : (23:28:45) ±Game: Hey partner stop attacking me, i am on your side!! (23:28:45) No one died! : (23:28:45) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:45) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Parasprites, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:28:45) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:28:45) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:28:45) ±Time: Day 2 (23:28:45) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (23:28:45) *************************************************************************************** (23:28:50) Truthful Karp: er (23:28:53) Truthful Karp: hello (23:29:07) Goobes: veteran is parapsirtes (23:29:08) Truthful Karp: im not parasprites (23:29:09) Goobes: but im not the detective (23:29:14) Truthful Karp: or changeling (23:29:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:29:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Parasprites, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:29:14) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Veteran Padgett, Xenon. (23:29:14) ±Current Team: Changeling, Parasprites (23:29:14) ±Time: Day 2 (23:29:14) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (23:29:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:29:16) Veteran Padgett: i'm the detective (23:29:20) Veteran Padgett: but i'm not parasprites (23:29:23) ±Game: Veteran Padgett voted for Goobes! (23:29:23) Crobat: I hate detectives (23:29:24) ±Game: Sky Sentinel voted for Veteran Padgett! (23:29:25) ±Game: Xenon voted for Goobes! (23:29:26) Goobes: then get bestbubz (23:29:26) ±Game: BestBubs. voted for Veteran Padgett! (23:29:29) Crobat: I am all about dresses (23:29:29) ±Game: Crobat voted for Veteran Padgett! (23:29:31) ±Game: Truthful Karp voted for Veteran Padgett! (23:29:32) ±Game: -Dranzer Kai- voted for Veteran Padgett! (23:29:41) Goobes: so confused now. all you liars (23:29:43) ±Dratini: yolo666. was mysteriously kicked by Strudels! (23:29:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:29:44) Times Up! : (23:29:44) ±Mayor Mare: Veteran Padgett (Parasprites) has been banished from Equestria! (23:29:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:29:44) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Berry Punch, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:29:44) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:29:44) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:29:44) ±Time: Night 3 (23:29:44) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (23:29:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:29:44) Xenon: pls (23:29:49) Crobat: so I lied (23:29:49) Crobat: ok (23:29:52) Truthful Karp: gj (23:29:53) Sky Sentinel: ? (23:29:54) ±Game: You have chosen to feedoff Sky Sentinel! (23:30:05) -Dranzer Kai-: not yet (23:30:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:30:14) Times Up! : (23:30:14) ±Game: Your target (Sky Sentinel) was poisoned! (23:30:14) No one died! : (23:30:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:30:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doctor Hooves, Doll Berry Punch, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:30:14) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:30:14) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:30:14) ±Time: Day 3 (23:30:14) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (23:30:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:30:19) Sky Sentinel: poisoned (23:30:22) Truthful Karp: omgus (23:30:23) Sky Sentinel: rarity is on brony (23:30:24) Xenon: brony is ganing power (23:30:39) Sky Sentinel: so rarity vote who youre on (23:30:43) Truthful Karp: rip (23:30:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:30:44) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doctor Hooves, Doll Berry Punch, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:30:44) ±Current Players: -Dranzer Kai-, BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:30:44) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:30:44) ±Time: Day 3 (23:30:44) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (23:30:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:30:47) Goobes: truthful karp is broney (23:30:51) Truthful Karp: i am (23:30:53) ±Game: Sky Sentinel voted for Truthful Karp! (23:30:54) Crobat: ._. (23:30:56) Goobes: is tha tbad (23:30:57) Truthful Karp: have been pled (23:30:58) xx trainer xx joined the channel. (23:31:01) Truthful Karp: for 2 nights (23:31:01) ±Game: -Dranzer Kai- voted for Sky Sentinel! (23:31:05) ±Game: BestBubs. voted for -Dranzer Kai-! (23:31:05) Truthful Karp: ? (23:31:06) -Dranzer Kai-: keep tied (23:31:06) ±Game: Crobat voted for Truthful Karp! (23:31:07) Crobat: huh? (23:31:09) Crobat: what are we doing (23:31:10) BestBubs.: fuck it (23:31:13) BestBubs.: -Dranzer Kai- is the bronie (23:31:14) Crobat: I thought brony was mafia (23:31:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:14) Times Up! : (23:31:14) ±Mayor Mare: -Dranzer Kai- (Doll Berry Punch) has been banished from Equestria! (23:31:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doctor Hooves, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (23:31:14) ±Current Players: BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Sky Sentinel, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:31:14) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:31:14) ±Time: Night 4 (23:31:14) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (23:31:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:18) BestBubs.: what the heck (23:31:20) ±Game: The Ponyville Residents is going to distract Truthful Karp! (23:31:21) Xenon: yes brony is the mafia (23:31:26) Truthful Karp: yeah (23:31:29) BestBubs.: huh (23:31:31) ±CommandBot: The command poison doesn't exist (23:31:34) ±Game: You have chosen to feedoff Goobes! (23:31:40) Goobes: then why not get broney (23:31:40) ±Game: You have chosen to feedoff BestBubs.! (23:31:41) Sky Sentinel: k spike ded (23:31:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:44) Times Up! : (23:31:44) ±Game: Your target (BestBubs.) was poisoned! (23:31:44) ±Mayor Mare: Sky Sentinel (Spike) has disappeared from Equestria! (23:31:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:44) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doctor Hooves, Rarity, Twilight Sparkle. (23:31:44) ±Current Players: BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:31:44) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:31:44) ±Time: Day 4 (23:31:44) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (23:31:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:31:46) Crobat: oh brony has voteshield (23:31:48) BestBubs.: right so (23:31:52) Xenon: go twilight sparkle (23:31:52) BestBubs.: Xenon is changeling (23:31:52) Xenon: imo (23:31:54) BestBubs.: posioned me (23:31:58) BestBubs.: and Truthful Karp is brony (23:32:02) Truthful Karp: yeah (23:32:04) Xenon: get the brony :c (23:32:08) Crobat: we need to get change first (23:32:14) BestBubs.: get changeling (23:32:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:32:14) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doctor Hooves, Rarity, Twilight Sparkle. (23:32:14) ±Current Players: BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Truthful Karp, Xenon. (23:32:14) ±Current Team: Changeling (23:32:14) ±Time: Day 4 (23:32:14) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (23:32:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:32:16) Xenon: get the brony first (23:32:16) ±Game: BestBubs. voted for Xenon! (23:32:17) ±Game: Goobes voted for Xenon! (23:32:18) Xenon: : ( (23:32:19) Crobat: you can't even lynch brony he has -5 voteshield (23:32:19) BestBubs.: no (23:32:23) Xenon: oh i c (23:32:40) Goobes: i could make a better FiM theme (23:32:43) Xenon: maybe (23:32:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:32:44) Times Up! : (23:32:44) ±Mayor Mare: Xenon (Changeling) has been banished from Equestria! (23:32:44) ±Game: Oh noes, now that all the bad guys are dead, the price of Brony's dolls has dropped down, now you have lost your now Brony is without voteshield (23:32:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:32:44) ±Current Roles: Broken Brony, Doctor Hooves, Rarity, Twilight Sparkle. (23:32:44) ±Current Players: BestBubs., Crobat, Goobes, Truthful Karp. (23:32:44) ±Time: Night 5 (23:32:44) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (23:32:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:32:44) BestBubs.: do it then (23:32:50) BestBubs.: ok get karp after this (23:32:51) Truthful Karp: fuck (23:32:51) BestBubs.: i'm out (23:32:52) BestBubs.: dead (23:32:55) Goobes: i'll need to wathjc more episodes (23:33:01) Truthful Karp: im broken (23:33:04) Crobat: lol Theme: FiM Author: Tesla Elesa and obey to kyubey Enabled: Yes Number of Players: 6 to 38 players Summary: Equestria, the land of ponies and friendship, is under attack! Discord and Queen Chrysalis have teamed up, ready to plunge Equestria into eternal chaos! At the same time, the Princesses decide to have a little fun, the Diamond Dogs seek to enslave ponykind, Trixie returns with her truly magical magic show, and Zecora works away mysteriously in her hut. Poor Derpy has no idea whose team she's on. Use the magic of friendship and work together as teams to win! PM Tesla Elesa any comments or suggestions, or post in this thread: http://pokemon-online.eu/forums/showthread.php?15907-FiM. UPDATE 36: Major balancing. See thread. (For more information about this theme, type /roles FiM, /sides FiM, /priority FiM and /changelog FiM) Code: http://pastebin.com/raw.php?i=u7T5ueRJ (23:33:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:14) Times Up! : (23:33:14) ±Mayor Mare: BestBubs. (Twilight Sparkle) has disappeared from Equestria! (23:33:14) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:14) ±Current Roles: Broken Brony, Doctor Hooves, Rarity. (23:33:14) ±Current Players: Crobat, Goobes, Truthful Karp. (23:33:14) ±Time: Day 5 (23:33:14) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (23:33:15) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:21) CrapAtRBY joined the channel. (23:33:22) Sky Sentinel: btw (23:33:25) Truthful Karp: lol (23:33:26) Sky Sentinel: its not -5 (23:33:30) Truthful Karp: its -2 (23:33:32) Crobat: it's 0 now (23:33:36) Sky Sentinel: no like (23:33:38) Truthful Karp: yeah (23:33:39) Sky Sentinel: it starts at 1.1 (23:33:43) Crobat: ohhh (23:33:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:44) ±Current Roles: Broken Brony, Doctor Hooves, Rarity. (23:33:44) ±Current Players: Crobat, Goobes, Truthful Karp. (23:33:44) ±Time: Day 5 (23:33:44) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (23:33:44) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:47) Crobat: so they did nerf it (23:33:48) Crobat: good (23:33:48) Sky Sentinel: -1 for every convert (23:33:50) ±Game: Crobat voted for Truthful Karp! (23:33:51) Sky Sentinel: yeah (23:33:55) ±Game: Goobes voted for Truthful Karp! (23:33:56) ±Game: Truthful Karp voted for Truthful Karp! (23:33:56) *************************************************************************************** (23:33:56) Times Up! : (23:33:56) ±Mayor Mare: Truthful Karp (Broken Brony) has been banished from Equestria! (23:33:56) ±Game: Due to the latest deaths, Doctor Hooves became Doctor Hooves! (23:33:56) ±Game: Due to the latest deaths, Rarity became Rarity! (23:33:56) ±Twilight Sparkle: Dear Princess Celestia, today I learned that through teamwork, you can overcome the toughest of adversaries! Goobes and Crobat are truly friends you can rely on! ~Your most faithful student, Twilight Sparkle you can tell I don't play FiM much but still hope it helps.
Sorry i never replied back to this, anyway i corrected that grammatically wrong message and another bug that leaves some village's roles still vclr even when Brony is no more there should be gone too. Anyway, i noticed that FiM wasn't played really much during march, so i wanted to ask if maybe the games with Brony are boring to play even now that his voteshield power is nerfed. Can someone tell me what they think about Brony on fun level?
Spoiler: game log as Brony (20:22:55) *************************************************************************************** (20:22:55) Times Up! : (20:22:55) The Roles have been Decided! : (20:22:55) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:22:55) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:22:55) ±Game: You have -1.1 voteshield. (20:22:55) ±Game: Your team is Espeon (Brony). (20:22:55) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Fluttershy, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:22:55) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Parasprites, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet, failsohard. (20:22:55) ±Current Team: Brony (20:22:55) ±Time: Night 1 (20:22:55) Make your moves, you only have 40 seconds! : (20:22:55) *************************************************************************************** (20:22:56) Scatterbrain: Who here thinks that the government is wiretapping them (20:22:57) Froby: fuzzzzyyy (20:23:05) +Espeon: I wanted Discord :( (20:23:07) [YM]SilentYoshi left the channel. (20:23:12) Scatterbrain: sudden dip in players (20:23:13) Parasprites: 1 short (20:23:16) Parasprites: bs (20:23:18) Scatterbrain: 18 ---> 11 (20:23:18) Domad4444 left the channel. (20:23:19) +Espeon: UMMMMMMM (20:23:22) Parasprites: why fim kill mafia (20:23:22) +Espeon: wrong channel, sorry (20:23:25) Parasprites: cri (20:23:27) failsohard: idk if I'm special or not :( (20:23:29) Ashton Irwin: Friendship is so not magic (20:23:30) failsohard: sad pony (20:23:31) Scatterbrain: Fim is a good theme actually (20:23:34) ±QueryBot: The aliases for the IP 69.171.163.55 are: silvershail (online), (20:23:34) [OG] SilentYoshi joined the channel. (20:23:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:23:35) Times Up! : (20:23:35) No one died! : (20:23:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:23:35) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Fluttershy, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:23:35) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Parasprites, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet, failsohard. (20:23:35) ±Current Team: Brony (20:23:35) ±Time: Day 1 (Standby) (20:23:35) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (20:23:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:23:37) Froby: Scatterbrain thats a proven fact (20:23:39) Parasprites: sp (20:23:42) Froby: lol think (20:23:43) Parasprites: Parasprites (20:23:43) i think he left the channel. (20:23:45) Parasprites: hate me (20:23:50) TheAdrienC: I'm inspect and I got a baddie (20:24:00) TheAdrienC: Espeon is Brony (20:24:04) SilversHail left the channel. (20:24:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:24:05) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Fluttershy, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:24:05) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Parasprites, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet, failsohard. (20:24:05) ±Current Team: Brony (20:24:05) ±Time: Day 1 (Voting) (20:24:05) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (20:24:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:24:06) Parasprites: last fluttershy here (20:24:07) ±Game: Parasprites voted for Parasprites! (20:24:09) failsohard: poisoned :/ (20:24:09) ±Game: TheAdrienC voted for Espeon! (20:24:12) Parasprites: pm ? (20:24:14) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:24:14) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:24:14) ±Game: You have -1.1 voteshield. (20:24:14) ±Game: Your team is Espeon (Brony). (20:24:17) Parasprites: anyone ? (20:24:18) TheAdrienC: Someone protect me (20:24:19) TheNewBrends11 left the channel. (20:24:20) ±Game: Ashton Irwin voted for Parasprites! (20:24:23) ±Game: Fuzzysqurl voted for Espeon! (20:24:30) Parasprites: Ashton Irwin is confirmed mafia (20:24:33) Parasprites: village vote it (20:24:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:24:35) Times Up! : (20:24:35) ±Mayor Mare: Parasprites (Fluttershy) has been banished from Equestria! (20:24:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:24:35) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:24:35) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet, failsohard. (20:24:35) ±Current Team: Brony (20:24:35) ±Time: Night 2 (20:24:35) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (20:24:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:24:46) Ashton Irwin: Hey, what do I care (20:24:47) TheAdrienC: ... (20:24:58) +Fuzzysqurl: presumably rarity was on you? (20:24:59) Scatterbrain: also since there are theme creators here: preventTeamvote is something now (20:25:01) failsohard: imma die now (20:25:04) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:25:04) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:25:04) ±Game: You have -1.1 voteshield. (20:25:04) ±Game: Your team is Espeon (Brony). (20:25:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:25:05) Times Up! : (20:25:05) ±Mayor Mare: failsohard (Pony) has disappeared from Equestria! (20:25:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:25:05) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:25:05) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet. (20:25:05) ±Current Team: Brony (20:25:05) ±Time: Day 2 (Standby) (20:25:05) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (20:25:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:25:05) Scatterbrain: read up on the forums (20:25:10) TheAdrienC: I'm the INSPECTOR and I got a Brony result on Espeon. (20:25:13) TheAdrienC: Vote!!! (20:25:15) Ashton Irwin: Presumably, I don't care (20:25:27) Ashton Irwin: I really don't (20:25:32) +Espeon: So which one is the voteshield? (20:25:33) LilyTheVaporeon left the channel. (20:25:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:25:35) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity, Spike, Twilight Sparkle. (20:25:35) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Froby, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, TheAdrienC, Violet. (20:25:35) ±Current Team: Brony (20:25:35) ±Time: Day 2 (Voting) (20:25:35) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (20:25:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:25:36) ±Game: Ashton Irwin voted for TheAdrienC! (20:25:37) ±Game: TheAdrienC voted for Espeon! (20:25:37) Froby: hey i need a slay (20:25:38) ±Game: Fuzzysqurl voted for Espeon! (20:25:39) ±Game: Violet voted for Espeon! (20:25:40) Dodioadjkl joined the channel. (20:25:41) +Espeon: reason (20:25:41) +Espeon: and shit (20:25:44) Froby: sistation going on (20:25:47) ±Slay: Froby will be slain by Espeon after the phase ends! (20:25:51) ±Game: Scatterbrain voted for Espeon! (20:25:53) +Espeon: situation*]I hope (20:25:55) Froby: thank (20:25:58) ±Game: Espeon voted for TheAdrienC! (20:26:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:05) Times Up! : (20:26:05) ±Mayor Mare: TheAdrienC (Twilight Sparkle) has been banished from Equestria! (20:26:05) ±Slay: Froby (Spike) was slain by Espeon! (20:26:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:05) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Parasprites, Pony, Pony, Pony, Rarity. (20:26:05) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:26:05) ±Current Team: Brony (20:26:05) ±Time: Night 3 (20:26:05) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (20:26:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:08) Dodioadjkl left the channel. (20:26:09) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:26:09) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:26:09) ±Game: You have -1.1 voteshield. (20:26:09) ±Game: Your team is Espeon (Brony). (20:26:10) Scatterbrain: GOD DAMN (20:26:10) Ashton Irwin: YES (20:26:12) +Fuzzysqurl: nice choke village (20:26:14) Dodioadjkl joined the channel. (20:26:19) +Espeon: >you have a -4.1 voteshield (20:26:23) +Espeon: >your voteshield is -1.1 (20:26:27) ±Game: You have chosen to collect Violet! (20:26:29) Luffy-sama left the channel. (20:26:29) Ashton Irwin: ik, blame Roild (20:26:33) Ashton Irwin: He's weird (20:26:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:35) Times Up! : (20:26:35) ±Game: Oh Yeah! Another piece added to Brony's collection, still 3 to go! (20:26:35) ±Game: You copied someone and changed roles! (20:26:35) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:26:35) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:26:35) ±Game: Your voteshield rised to -2.1. (20:26:35) ±Game: Your team is Espeon (Brony). (20:26:35) ±Game: A Pony has been converted into a Doll Bon Bon! (20:26:35) ±Game: Your target (Violet) has been converted and is now a Doll Bon Bon! (20:26:35) No one died! : (20:26:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:35) ±Current Roles: Berry Punch, Brony, Changeling, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Parasprites, Rarity. (20:26:35) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:26:35) ±Current Team: Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:26:35) ±Time: Day 3 (Standby) (20:26:35) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (20:26:35) *************************************************************************************** (20:26:39) Roild: Fuzzy did it (20:26:40) Scatterbrain: Roild isn't the author :( (20:26:43) +Fuzzysqurl: what did i do (20:26:46) Scatterbrain: wait (20:26:47) +Espeon: >voteshield raised to 2.1 (20:26:52) +Espeon: >voteshield still -4 (20:26:58) +Fuzzysqurl: ??? (20:26:58) Ashton Irwin: Roles still says -1.1 lmao (20:27:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:27:05) ±Current Roles: Berry Punch, Brony, Changeling, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Parasprites, Rarity. (20:27:05) ±Current Players: Ashton Irwin, Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:27:05) ±Current Team: Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:27:05) ±Time: Day 3 (Voting) (20:27:05) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (20:27:05) *************************************************************************************** (20:27:07) +Fuzzysqurl: wtf you talking about espeon? your help is dumb? (20:27:09) Scatterbrain: don't expect the theme creators to be gods (20:27:09) Roild: Post in the thread. Obey will fix. :P (20:27:10) ±Game: Fuzzysqurl voted for Ashton Irwin! (20:27:11) +Espeon: yes it is (20:27:14) ±Game: Ashton Irwin voted for Fuzzysqurl! (20:27:16) ±Dratini: snorlaxisbeast was mysteriously kicked by Espeon! (20:27:17) Scatterbrain: i am also berry punch (20:27:20) ±Game: Scatterbrain voted for Fuzzysqurl! (20:27:22) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:27:22) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:27:22) ±Game: Your voteshield rised to -2.1. (20:27:22) ±Game: Your team is Violet (Doll Bon Bon) and Espeon (Brony). (20:27:22) ±Game: The Doll Bon Bon is Violet! (20:27:22) Scatterbrain: vote ashton (20:27:27) Ashton Irwin: Go right on ahead (20:27:29) Scatterbrain: since he's related to ashton kutcher (20:27:31) Ashton Irwin: Espeon has this (20:27:33) ±Game: Espeon voted for Fuzzysqurl! (20:27:34) +Espeon: no? (20:27:36) +Fuzzysqurl: pls (20:27:36) Ashton Irwin: Don't ya buddy (20:27:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:27:41) Times Up! : (20:27:41) ±Mayor Mare: Ashton Irwin (Parasprites) has been banished from Equestria! (20:27:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:27:41) ±Current Roles: Berry Punch, Brony, Changeling, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Rarity. (20:27:41) ±Current Players: Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Scatterbrain, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:27:41) ±Current Team: Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:27:41) ±Time: Night 4 (20:27:41) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (20:27:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:27:43) +Espeon: oh nice vote of 0 (20:27:46) +Fuzzysqurl: yeah (20:27:49) Scatterbrain: i saved you (20:27:51) Scatterbrain: come and get me (20:27:56) Scatterbrain: f1t3 m3 (20:27:57) kirax7 left the channel. (20:27:57) ±Game: You have chosen to collect Pangaea! (20:28:08) +Espeon: brony sucks no offense :/ (20:28:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:28:11) Times Up! : (20:28:11) ±Game: Shiny gems! Pretty dresses! Wait, were you supposed to be doing something? Stupid Rarity. (20:28:11) ±Mayor Mare: Scatterbrain (Berry Punch) has disappeared from Equestria! (20:28:11) ±Game: You have 1 days to live. (20:28:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:28:11) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Rarity. (20:28:11) ±Current Players: Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:28:11) ±Current Team: Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:28:11) ±Time: Day 4 (Standby) (20:28:11) You have 30 seconds to debate who are the bad guys! : (20:28:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:28:15) +Fuzzysqurl: yes they do (20:28:16) +Espeon: hey (20:28:18) +Espeon: lynch changeling (20:28:20) +Espeon: and you win (20:28:28) +Espeon: because they poisoned me, lol (20:28:33) +Fuzzysqurl: lol (20:28:38) Spencroxisfat: no (20:28:39) ±Game: You are a Brony! (20:28:39) ±Game: Doesn't matter if Friendship is Magic is made for kids, you love that show: sadly your favourite characters fear strange animals that stands on two legs no fur and that plays mafia on Pokemon Online, but don't worry: you can convert them to your version of friendship using /collect if your target is a villager, otherwise you will simply weaken your targets leaving them with only 0,5 vote power and weakened powers. You have a voteshield of -4.1 but your vote power is 0. Because you cannot kill and your vote is 0 your only way to win is that to /collect 4 villagers before that all the mafia roles are killed by the village. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:28:39) ±Game: Your voteshield rised to -2.1. (20:28:39) ±Game: Your team is Violet (Doll Bon Bon) and Espeon (Brony). (20:28:39) ±Game: The Doll Bon Bon is Violet! (20:28:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:28:41) ±Current Roles: Brony, Changeling, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Rarity. (20:28:41) ±Current Players: Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Spencroxisfat, Violet. (20:28:41) ±Current Team: Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:28:41) ±Time: Day 4 (Voting) (20:28:41) It's time to vote someone off, type /Vote [name], you only have 30 seconds! : (20:28:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:28:49) +Espeon: in that case (20:28:51) ±Game: Espeon voted for Spencroxisfat! (20:28:52) +Espeon: go go go (20:28:53) Spencroxisfat: i don't wanna be lynched (20:28:55) ±Game: Fuzzysqurl voted for Spencroxisfat! (20:29:00) Rosina left the channel. (20:29:00) Spencroxisfat: I'm changeling (20:29:03) +Espeon: welp (20:29:04) Spencroxisfat: stop (20:29:05) +Espeon: win for village (20:29:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:29:11) Times Up! : (20:29:11) ±Mayor Mare: Spencroxisfat (Changeling) has been banished from Equestria! (20:29:11) ±Game: Oh noes, now that all the bad guys are dead, the price of Brony's dolls has dropped down, now Brony is without voteshield (20:29:11) ±Game: You are a Broken Brony! (20:29:11) ±Game: Now that you have lost your voteshield after the fall of the dolls market: you have no defense during the vote phase apart your partners votes, you can still /collect ponies but now this command fail 50% of the time. Use /tt to Talk with your teammates. (20:29:11) ±Game: You don't have a voteshield any longer. (20:29:11) ±Game: Your team is Violet (Doll Bon Bon) and Espeon (Broken Brony). (20:29:11) ±Game: The Doll Bon Bon is Violet! (20:29:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:29:11) ±Current Roles: Broken Brony, Doll Bon Bon, Lyra, Rarity. (20:29:11) ±Current Players: Espeon, Fuzzysqurl, Pangaea, Violet. (20:29:11) ±Current Team: Broken Brony, Doll Bon Bon (20:29:11) ±Time: Night 5 (20:29:11) Make your moves, you only have 30 seconds! : (20:29:11) *************************************************************************************** (20:29:16) Violet: </3 (20:29:20) +Espeon: hey I am broken and poisoned (20:29:27) +Espeon: it can't possibly get worse (20:29:30) ±Game: You have chosen to collect Fuzzysqurl! (20:29:33) +Fuzzysqurl: and you're distracted (20:29:35) +Espeon: oh it can (20:29:39) +Espeon: DEATH (20:29:41) *************************************************************************************** (20:29:41) Times Up! : (20:29:41) ±Game: Shiny gems! Pretty dresses! Wait, were you supposed to be doing something? Stupid Rarity. (20:29:41) ±Game: You died because of poison! (20:29:41) ±Mayor Mare: Espeon (Broken Brony) has disappeared from Equestria! (20:29:41) ±Twilight Sparkle: Dear Princess Celestia, today I learned that through teamwork, you can overcome the toughest of adversaries! Pangaea, Violet and Fuzzysqurl are truly friends you can rely on! ~Your most faithful student, Twilight Sparkle (20:29:41) *************************************************************************************** Some inconsistencies there. Might want to fix them.
Diamond dogs are severely underpowered in smaller games , even when fido spawns it's barely equal ,and it gets weaker as the games get larger (and roles like cutie mark and queen chryselis spawns) it's last role has no power
@Shazan I recommended Tyrek. I think it would be a good role to add to the theme. Tyrek would be a Godfather that can win with Discord (n1-n4) but then only wins alone (n5- beyond). Tyrek could be something like a Kefka kill, that can't be haxed, but can be Pled. He could also have access to /inspect. Since Tyrek morphs Ponies in the Show, a convert action could be a possible idea.
up to the third role for each side it's mostly balanced between mafias and roughly village with fido rover spot discord changeling parasprites and village ,(dogs are a little weak but that's halfway acceptable) but as the later spawns come up , the diamond dogs are completely outmatched by the other main sides, compared to discord axis,1 reason is that their final role spawns not only very late but also has no extra power, here is a quote from /roles (08:29:09) ±Role: Queen Chrysalis (08:29:09) ±Ability: The leader of the Changelings. Can consume (poison, goes through safeguard) one pony's emotions during the night. Can't be distracted. Can convert into Princess Cadance. Has a voteshield of -5. May find Discord. Reveals as a random role when inspected. Sided with Discord-Chrysalis Axis. (08:29:09) ±Players: 20-30 Players (08:29:12) ±Role: Diamond Dog (08:29:12) ±Ability: A dog that inhabits the mines. Can kidnap one pony (shared) during the night. Sided with Diamond Dogs. (08:29:12) ±Players: 25-38 Players
This theme too has been elected for this Quality Assurance section because in the previous months it was between the underplayed one. Spoiler: Quality Assurance §3.3- Quality Assurance Every month a small group of themes will undergo a quality assurance process. During this process, Reviewers and the current Theme Owner(s) will discuss various aspects of the theme to assure the theme is up to par with current standards and give feedback on ways to improve the theme. While in discussion, the theme will stay enabled on the server to help provide live feedback to various changes. The theme will also be immune from removal for Activity or Quality while undergoing this process. There is no designated selection process or limit but generally the same theme will not undergo this process more than twice a year. So @Cheezeburgar @Sky Sentinel @Pandaofazn @Fiery Espeon @EljayQuiz and @Joeypals!! it's time to discuss about this theme future good luck!
So, I'll get the conversation started, though I can't make a complete review atm. Starting off with flavor. The theme creatively incorporates a lot of minor characters as villagers, but instead of making mass-claiming instantly break any game, they don't know who they are for the first couple nights. Almost every important character is represented up through the second season as far as I can tell, and the only role that stands out as strange is the Brony - it just seems to break the context of the theme, maybe a bit too meta. The sides are a bit silly, but they work out anyway (despite Twilight and Celestia being on opposite sides) A couple minor adjustments could be made to mechanics. /roles fim is filled with doubles, I think of the roles which can be Brony'd. The replicas could be given "hide": "true" Some of the win conditions are illogical. Celestia, for instance, has TS under WinIfDeadRoles, which would make sense because Twilight can daykill, except for the fact that Celestia is immune to daykills. There are a couple similar discrepancies that came up in discussion a while ago, though I don't recall all of them now. Another concern mechanics-wise is that a lot of Power Roles can hax each other. I'll have to look more in detail to be sure, but it seems a little overpowered on the surface.
I'm in agreeance with WU on this one. Flavor-wise, you've got as many good things going for it as bad. On the bright side, you incorporate every character you possibly can--both major and minor--in a way that doesn't seem overly cluttered, and the amnesiac villagers add an extra nice touch to that. On the downside, you have Twilight and Celestia on opposite sides for some reason (made even odder when you consider the win message for the village) and the Brony creating an odd context as it creates a universe where the ponies (and others) are aware that there's a guy who looks like the one in the spoiler watching them instead of focusing on the actual show itself. Spoiler: ...ew As far as hax goes, I don't think it's too big of a concern to have the PRs hax each other, since everything besides protect can be haxed and there's multiple ways for Twilight to be found. I'll put a list of the roles Celestia should have under WinIfDead below, but besides that I don't think I have much to add. Spot Rover Fido Diamond Dog All Zecora forms King Sombra Parasprites Rainbow Dash Applejack Trixie, Discord, and Twilight were the ones removed from the list.
The reason FIM has been so underplayed recently, in my opinion, is not because of the balance/unbalance of the theme. 1) There is a decrease in players who know what FIM is, and so do not start it. We cannot control this, and this is due to overall PO player decrease. 2) Like any theme, when someone decides to "update"a theme, the Mafia community is against it. I can contribute the decrease in players, with the addition of Brony and the nonpeak setup. All underplayed themes are usually underplayed because of this reason. It's not because of a balancing issue. I mean, if there is hax involved, I would want to play it more. I would suggest removing the Brony setup for now, and seeing if people play it more often or the same and go for the more classic Discord vs Pinkie Pie and Twilight Sparkle, is nostalgic, and people will play it more. Feel free to disagree with me. However, I do not disagree with the technical flaws that Joeypals and Whereabouts Unknown mentioned, as those do need to be fixed.
As a blanket statement, I'm going to say this is false. There are counterexamples. It is probably true that once something is positioned for change there will always be others who want the change to occur differently, which is why adopted themes are often subject to criticism. However, a theme does not inherently become less popular when updated. Updating themes (as necessary) is kind of the purpose of QA. That said, I do feel as though the Brony setup is awkward and anti-canon. It could work I guess. Though in any case, the mechanical or textual errors relating to Brony that were brought up earlier in this thread should be resolved.
Hmmm I tought I removed the double roles from the infos, oh well better check it again. Hmmm about Celestia and Luna I have no idea why they are on a different side then the other ponies @Tesla Elesa added them before of my adoption of the theme, probably is related with the meme Trollestia but I am not sure. Personally I don't think I could add them to the village because it is already full of Prs so i guess I could at least remove them completely from the game and add 2 other bad guys instead of them but I have no idea who could i add, Maybe I could add Nightmere Moon instead then Princess Luna but I have no idea who could substitute Celestia. Any suggestion? Spoiler: Yes she's looking at you, run!!! Hmmm, if you want i can return to the original setup and remove the Brony even if it was a little unbalanced , otherwise if the Brony is a problem because is more a meta-thing then an actual part of the show I could simply modify it into Tirek leaving him with the same powers but different names and messages,let me know what of the 2 ideas you like more. That setup "Discord vs Pinkie Pie and Twilight Sparkle" is always there, I never modified that part of the game, Brony was added only as addiction for the village vs paraspryte and changeling because playing the bad guys on that setup was often a sure victory, but I didn't wanted to modify the game more then necessary, this is why the part of the game where discord spawn is as the old one, maybe you didn't saw it because lately there weren't enough player to play that setup. Wait What!?! I never added any non-peak feature for this theme. I never received any complaint about the hax of this theme, even because most of this prs cannot spam their ability otherwise roles like changeling will discover them and the Lead Roles cannot reveal themselves freely because the protectors cannot protect them from everything, as extra their own hax can be a double edged weapon because if Brony or King Sombra convert them: then they can reveal to them who they haxed, and if I remember i modified the hax so that it will be more hard to make a complete connection because all this prs hax a different pony then the one who could hax them. More or less their hax is some sort of chain which can connect all of them through a pretty slow word to mouth feature. Hmmm I have some difficulty to explain but it's something like: Inspector haxes→Protector haxes→Distractor haxes→BulletProof haxes→Vigilantes haxes→Nothing; in this exemple we can see that Inspector can discover with hax who is the Vigilantes but to do it the information needs to pass throug the BulletProof then the Distractor and last the Protector, so it will take a while to receive the info.
I like this idea. I know almost nothing about Tirek, but if it works within canon then I think it's better. I should really catch up in the show. As for Celestia/Luna, I think they're fine as a faction, especially because the village easily has enough PRs without. Perhaps some extra explanatory flavor could help their opposition make sense. Now that you explained the hax it seems fine. It was kind of hard to follow and/or get a sense of how freely they can be spammed when I was looking at the code, but it certainly seems well thought out.
Well in the past I tought about a non-peak version which takes advantage about the not-vanilla feature of the village, where there is Twilight the inspector + a bad guy and some villagers ponies. This bad guy will be unable to kill during the first 2 or 3 nights but will be capable to disguise himself as one of the villagers on his choice apart twilight, for exemple typing /doctor, /hooves or /doctor hooves he will be inspected as the villager "Doctor Hooves". The villagers names will be visible inside the current players list but the players will be unable to know what villager they are until twilight will inspect them. Practically if Twilight will find out two players with the same role she will know that one of them is the bad guy. The motive why i didn't implemented this non-peak version was because I was unsure if as gameplay this non-peak would be good and because I don't know any evil role which would be suitable for such ability on flavour level apart changeling which is already a role, at the beginning I tought to make it into a "Ponyta" as some sort of connection with the pokemon server but I tought it was a little too much meta like it was the Brony. The only unused bad guy I could use perhaps is Nightmare Moon because of her illusion powers but i am unsure and until now the only episodes of the show I haven't see are the movie one like "Equestria Girls" so I don't know if that bad guys could be suitable for this role.
I would suggest Tirek, as he is able to "suck" the powers out of ponies, and gain their powers, so Twilight might get confused on which is the real pony
Hi guys, sorry if lately i have been absent lately. Anyway I added nightmare moon for non peak games and transformed Barony into Tyrek to make it more flavor like or at least until I will not find a way to make the brony's spawn size more similar to the original film but without the unbalancement. If you have some idea how to do it I will be happy to hear.