Well, for RedJoker25, idk. It could easily be I've just been overlooking him to much. It just seems to me that with Meow and Water as partners, they would encourage him to post far more than he did. As for Marcello., I think that he's most likely village sided. He's been acting village-oriented throughout the game, and moving things along. He hasn't really gone along with a bandwagon at all or been suspiciously eager to get people lynched. Also, I don't think the mafia would try and have two people within the village leadership. Depending on what kind of people where in the game, you might have an inspector who checked all the leader-ish people, in which case your team would be discovered pretty easily. Also, if one got revealed, people would become highly suspicious of the other "leaders", so over all it just doesn't seem like the best idea. I could be wrong, but that's just my opinion.
Votecount: Jalmont (1): RedJoker25 Redjoker25 (3): Vintage Books, Jalmont, Marcello. Not voting (6): LordKX, IFM, Archerknight, Marcello., Nexus, TheSexiOne, Fitzy With 10 players remaining, it takes 6 votes to lynch. Deadline is Saturday, September 15th at 8 PM EST.
The Chance for IFM being scum is very high indeed. Excellent timing on the claim VB, but I wouldn't hurry on Lynching Redjoker25 yet. He's been playing well recently and to be fair I don't know what more he could do. Me hooking IFM and VB narrowing down the suspects tells me thats our best hope for now. Suggestions?
Exactly how were you expecting me to react to prods about being quiet? People wanted me to post more, so I've tried to. You said you questioned whether I had read the thread, so I posted something that I thought would prove that I had i.e. piece by piece commentary on the game. As for me finding evidence on jalmont, I've been attempting to prod him for a while. Naturally, I wanted more evidence to support my prod so it wasn't completely based on the same D2/3 observations again and again. I think a few of my points were worth looking at, but I guess not. In any case, I've already stated I don't think jal is scummy anymore due to his change of pace. My one vote isn't going to be majority on its own and I gave reasoning as to why I kept it. As for who to change to, I'm not sure, so I'm going to Unvote
When I get voted out and I'm clean I want you to take a very careful look at Archerknight. I've had suspicions of him for a while now and I think he should be the PL target for tonight. GL for the rest of the game you will need it. Vote Archerknight
I am extremely sorry IFM, I admire you as a player, but with the PL results, I have no choice. Vote IFM
Just posting now that I have read the last few posts, but need to go now for a chess match, so I won't get time to post now. I will have some time tomorrow night (6:00pm maybe?)
I agree and understand that IFM is perfectly capable of being scum and giving the impression he is villager, however, that still doesn't explain why he went out of his way to try and keep the day phase open when we voted MeowMix. Not only was it in no way positive for any scum aligned player, it was also glaringly obvious we were all voting anyway, meaning the scum only had to post a lynch against MeowMix in order to "blend into" the village. I think we should wait for now and try to see how Archerknight defends himself, and if his defense is adequate I will side with an IFM lynch.
Votecount: Redjoker25 (2): Jalmont, Marcello. IFM (2): Vintage Books, TheSexiOne Archerknight (1): IFM Not voting (5): LordKX, Archerknight, Nexus, RedJoker25, Fitzy With 10 players remaining, it takes 6 votes to lynch. Deadline is Saturday, September 15th at 8 PM EST.
Just wanted to say that my activity will be decreasing pretty soon. Also, for the time we have before the lynch deadline, what do we want to discuss? I'm thinking probably night actions, and if we have the time, we might want to even plan out the next couple of day's lynches. After all, we have 10 player, most likely 2 mafia, and a stalker and PL, and a number of "cleaned" people. So based on that, we should be able to figure out a way to maximize out chances of winning provided nothing unexpected happens.
I'll post big later but this just struck my mind if we should trust VB all out on his claim? Does anyone have any counter claims, if yes please do it now.
It's a possibility that he is lying, but the chances of him "protecting" anyone are low seeing as if he were Mafia he shouldn't have any teammates left.
Well he wouldn't be protecting he would be trying to force a vote on a villager. So he claims that one of three people could be mafia. He simply gets us to vote one today, vote another tomorrow because we assume we just picked the wrong one of the three. Puts him in a great position but also makes him a high priority target for the WW.
I'm going to make this brief because I need to practice piano (yes I have a very busy life). I'll try and post later if I get a chance. I've been played village-based through the game. I tried extending the day when everyone agreed on voting Xinc by removing my vote, before everything went a bit chaotic. I've always asked questions regarding people's decisions, to make sure they are justified. I've also participated in discussions and posted every 24h that I can. Vintage's and Nexus' claim both seem legit, because there have been no counter-claims, so we could assume that his information is true. However, if the whole mafia decide to kill someone, the individuals who maybe didn't send the kill maybe won't have visited anyone, so we cannot assume that all of those people are clean, especially when MeowMix and Water, both active and experienced players would probably decide on the kills. There is a high chance that they are indeed villager based, but we cannot let them fly totally under the radar and feeling that they don't need to contribute anymore. If I get time after practice, I'll try and post again. If not, tomorrow should be okay after school.
It is unlikely Vintage is lying. As IFM pointed out, this puts him in a position where he essentially can not win - the Lone Killer will just kill him off at his leisure. This means if Vintage is lying, he will not win the game, making this gambit entirely useless. Vintage has absolutely nothing to gain from lying, given the fact the only thing he achieves in doing so is temporarily redirecting attention waiting for the Lone Killer to kill him off and most likely end up winning the game (something which Vintage does not want, regardless of whether he is Village or scum).
Then this idea of picking one target to lynch per day is exactly what he needs to win unless mafia targets him. Also, TSO got two votes while I got none in the count. I should be under 'not voting.'
It doesn't matter what Vintages real role is at this time - his claim has essentially ensured his death regardless. The only problem it could pose to the village if he is lying is the fact it puts the other killer in a very good position to go on and win the game should we not manage to root them out.
He's going to get killed tonight anyway, if he is lying then it'd be 1 role vs the rest of the village, no? Not that good of a position.
sorry nicehat ive been really busy these few days with pocl and shit. ANYWAYS yeah I am not lying. Seeing as though there is (assumed) 2 killers alive, if i was one of those I would die resulting in me losing. But yeah, we should vote someone and archer rj25 and ifm are our best options. And the fact that ifm was hooked makes me think him as bad even more.
You have some things pointing to me being mafia, ie Vintage and Nexus, but then you have every other aspect of the game pointing against it. Really makes you wonder if I am the best lynch. Also we haven't considered that the vigi could have randed night 1 and hasn't done it since after I told him not to rand because you are more likely to hit village. If we have a vigi that follows that please step forward. That would also account for only one kill the last two nights and would mean that the mafia team would have 2-3 players left.
Let's look at our playerlist now. Vintage Books Jalmont Redjoker25 LordKX IFM fitzy TheSexiOne Archerknight Nexus Marcello. So let's look at who is likely village based on claims and such. vintage books (claimed watcher) Nexus (claimed hooker) It's likely that both are village, although it's not unheard of for the mafia to have either of these roles. Nexus is cleaned by virtue of Water, the mafia hooker already being dead. vintage right now is village. He will most likely die tonight. If he doesn't we will have to take a closer look at him. That being said, the mafia has to kill him, or risk having a PR floating around that could possibly find out the last 1 or 2 of them. LordKX Marcello. fitzy S3xid4n All are most likely villagers based on claims and vintage's results. Marcello. claiming is a bit odd, as I think it's really been an anomaly compared to how he's played this game. If my plan doesn't work we need to look at him closely as well. That leaves IFM, RJ25, and Archer. I can say with absolute confidence that I do not believe he is scum. No scum would extend the day to allow extra discussion. Right now, our best plan is to lynch either RJ or Archer. Depending on how that turns out, we lynch Archer the next day if RJ flips villy. Nexus should hook ARhcer if RJ is villy. If RJ is scum, Nexus should consider hooking Archer anyways or Marcello/tso. If either or are mafia that puts us in a very good position towards the end. if neither are mafia we have others we can look out. At this point this is our best option imo. I obviously did not include myself as I know I'm village.
While I maintain that I don't believe RJ is scum, I'll go along with this since I believe IFM still has lots to contribute. Vote: Redjoker25 Also, I'm voting now cause I might not get access to the forums at a later date.
Excellent Logic. Either me/VB get killed next night but still one is enough to find out the next Scum. I'll hook archer and hope for the best. VB should use his ability wisely on someone else. Vote Redjoker25
We shouldn't hammer RJ until we've fully decided upon what we're doing during the night phase (although I am entirely prepared to lynch RJ). Just because I'm a little curious, when you say I "claimed", what do you mean? I don't think I've specifically claimed any role thus far.
Does this not apply to me when I unvoted Xinc to extend the day to allow more discussion? Also, I'm happy to lynch RedJoker, seeing as he is probably the best candidate. Apart from trying to extend the day to allow extra discussion, what else has IFM done? He was PLed, and there was only one kill.
Don't know about others but this post reeks of scum to me. Actions: Nexus will PL IFM. We vote RJ25. We get Archer tomorrow depending how results roll. vintage should track a suspect but he should die because the mafia i assume aren't dumb This is the plan. I think RJ is most likely to be scum anyways, especially after nobody hammered his vote. If he was village you would think that a mafioso would've hammered
Votecount: Redjoker25 (5): Jalmont, Marcello., Vintage Books, LordKX, Nexus Archerknight (1): IFM Not voting (4): Archerknight, fitzy, RedJoker25, TheSexiOne With 10 players remaining, it takes 6 votes to lynch. Deadline is Saturday, September 15th at 8 PM EST. (note: this is tomorrow)
Jalmont, I had a feeling you were referring to that, but given the fact you felt it went against my general play style so far, I felt that you might've meant something a little more recent. Sorry for the misunderstanding.