if you dont mind me asking, how would this not be a popularity contest just like before? though it is better then the current way >.> lucky i got in because slim randomly added me lol
It would be based on the way you nominate players. For a theme like this, I would nominate based on what people are known for. I.e. I would nominate Serp for Serpranding or Cake for his holy Pineapple, these kind of things work so much better as it puts in mafia players who would actually be remembered, rather than just people who happen to be popular (its more of a talent show than a Popularity contest (except that the talents are more traits.)
HER HER HER but thanks :D ...now I can't say the idea makes sense because I'd sound biased. I thought it made sense before I saw this, I promise D:
The basis for most people's arguments now are that the people who don't like it are mad because they're not in the theme and the people who do like it only do because they are in it... ._. Which results in a rather poor argument...
I have no problem with not being in it, particularly because I won't kiss ass. The theme makes little sense(Kogent + Chaos on a team) and is all based from a personal view point, Ex. You're evil Kogent so you're evil in my theme-Sabrina.
I don't even really want a players theme. But if one is forced to be made, yes. Make the good people the actual good players who have proven it. Serp, Chaos, etc. Make the bad players people who truly suck. As in, they vote out inspector constantly, they fail with their PRs, etc. If they're gonna be hurt by that, then they're being hurt every game they play and they get a PR by the shit they get.
But I don't mind being an evil role if it's a loner one like Meta/Seph/MDA x3 And the problem with that is people might see it as flaming... Alternate but similar idea; it's all good players chosen in the same way as you suggest but some of them can volunteer to be evil roles?
If people volunteer to be an evil role they can be. However, like I said, if they see it as a form of flaming then they've obviously been flamed quite a bit already to have made it on without volunteering.
I heard this theme was played a few times but then it got disabled. Should we keep talking about this or should we lock this thread?
wtf, y did this happen? Besides, I still think we shouldnt talk in this anymore because the theme was already made, and therefore, theres no point in trying to develop a theme that has already been made.
Exactly! Put people in the theme who deserve it or have something special or neat about them, not your friends and people who want to be in it. I would also like the theme to be updated with players that are active right now, there are too many players on their that I haven't seen once (I've been playing for about a month thus making them inactive.)
IKR. BS make the villagers people who ACTUALLY suck at Mafia. I consider Jaxen a good player and Cirno was decent when he was here. And make the PRs ppl who are ACTUALLY good. For example, lordholiday never plays. Still, i would just change the role names. And yeah, making yourself OP with the inspect+kill combo. If that OPness is not there... that's amazingly cool.
I don't find Inspecting + Killing that helpful, it only is if you hit an unimportant role so you can skip killing them. Otherwise, you would most likely be randkilling the person you inspected anyway. The thing that makes Sabrina's team OP is that her partners distract. So, if she finds a killer, she can tell her partners and potentially stall an entire team while they pick everyone else off. And LordHoliday plays, just kinda late at night.
This. I see him sometimes when I'm up reaaaaaally epically late like when I fell asleep at 7pm and woke up at 1am. x3 (I'm guessing you mean one of the US times there x3) I still volunteer to be WW though or another alone evil role x3
Am I the only one that just doesn't care if they are in a theme or not? Seriously, there is more important things in life than being in a mafia theme imo.
lol. Good point. btw, u made a grammer error: there are more important things. Anyways, my life is only mafia, nothing else.